Episode 103 - Hosted by Jill Mastroianni
“Avoid probate at all costs!” It's advice you've probably heard. But is probate really the biggest problem your family could face after you die?
In this episode of The Death Readiness Podcast: Not Your Dad’s Estate Planning Podcast, estate planning attorney Jill Mastroianni examines two famous probate estates—Michael Jackson's and Aretha Franklin's—to explore why avoiding probate doesn't necessarily prevent family disputes, expensive litigation, or complicated estate administration.
You'll also hear real-life examples of what can go wrong when assets pass outside probate, including missing beneficiary designations, inherited retirement accounts, and financial institutions that make transferring assets unnecessarily difficult.
What You'll Learn in This Episode
What probate actually is and why people want to avoid it. Probate is the court-supervised process of administering someone's probate estate after death. It involves collecting assets, paying debts and expenses, and distributing property to the people entitled to receive it. Avoiding probate can be a worthwhile estate planning goal, but it shouldn't come at any cost.
Why Michael Jackson's estate is still being administered more than 17 years after his death. Michael Jackson had both a Will and a trust, yet his estate remains the subject of litigation. His daughter Paris Jackson recently petitioned the court to require a preliminary distribution of $600 million to the Michael Jackson Family Trust. The dispute illustrates why transferring assets into a trust doesn't necessarily resolve disagreements over how those assets should be managed.
What a pour-over Will does—and doesn't do. A pour-over Will directs assets remaining in someone's probate estate into a trust after death. But those assets must pass through probate before reaching the trust. Creating a revocable trust alone doesn't guarantee that your estate will avoid probate.
How three handwritten Wills complicated Aretha Franklin's estate. After the Queen of Soul died in 2018, three handwritten documents were discovered in her home, including one under a couch cushion. Years of litigation followed, and a Michigan jury eventually determined that the 2014 document was her valid Will. The case illustrates the importance of clear, accessible estate planning documents.
Why a trust doesn't guarantee your family will avoid litigation. Trusts can offer privacy, flexibility, and probate avoidance, but they don't eliminate disagreements among beneficiaries, unclear instructions, or disputes over estate administration.
Why beneficiary designations don't always make inheritance easy. Retirement accounts and other assets with designated beneficiaries generally pass outside probate. But outdated or incorrect beneficiary information, missing contact details, and uncooperative financial institutions can make collecting an inheritance surprisingly difficult.
How trying to avoid probate can create bigger estate planning problems. Adding a child to your house deed or bank account may seem like an easy probate avoidance strategy, but it can expose your property to risks involving the child's creditors or divorce.
What you can do now to make estate administration easier. Thoughtful estate planning includes reviewing beneficiary designations, organizing financial information, communicating with the people you've appointed to help you, and making sure they know where to find important documents.
Resources & Links
Related Episodes
Episode 19 — Why You Need (or Don't Need) a Trust
Learn how trusts work, when they can help you avoid probate, and whether a trust makes sense for your estate planning goals. https://www.deathreadiness.com/podcast/episode-19-how-to-know-if-you-need-a-trustEpisode 90 — Why You Shouldn't Add Your Child to Your Deed or Bank Account
Explore the potential legal and financial consequences of adding a child to your assets as a probate avoidance strategy.
o Audio: https://www.deathreadiness.com/podcast/90
o Video: https://youtu.be/3tlGkQk1Sac
Celebrity Estate Planning Cases
Michael Jackson's Will — Review the pour-over Will directing assets from his probate estate into the Michael Jackson Family Trust. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YvuS9nhZBx4z0q5l5ccBFIhoMUvhHx2k/view?usp=drivesdk
Aretha Franklin's Handwritten Wills — Examine the handwritten documents discovered after her death, including the 2014 document a Michigan jury determined was her valid Will.
June 21, 2010 document: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6020949-Aretha-Franklin-Handwritten-Will-1.html
October 20, 2010 document: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6020065-Aretha-Franklin-Handwritten-Will-2.html
March 31, 2014 document: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6020977-Aretha-Franklin-Handwritten-Will-3.html
Stay Connected. Subscribe to the Death Readiness Dispatch
Every Wednesday morning, Jill shares practical estate planning information, resources, behind-the-scenes stories, and occasional glimpses into life beyond the podcast.
Subscribe for free at deathreadiness.com/subscribe.
Get help with your Tennessee estate planning: https://www.deathreadiness.com/estate-planning-solution
Take the Next Step with The Death Readiness Playbook
Estate planning can feel overwhelming, especially when you don't know what you don't know.
The Death Readiness Playbook is an educational guide and hands-on workbook that helps you understand the legal, financial, and practical considerations involved in preparing for incapacity and death.
Through plain-English explanations, real-life examples, and practical worksheets, you'll learn what questions to ask, what decisions to consider, and how to organize the information your loved ones may someday need.
Whether you're just beginning to think about estate planning or already have documents in place, the Playbook helps you take the next step.
Explore The Death Readiness Playbook at https://www.deathreadiness.com/playbook
Connect with Jill:
· Website: https://www.deathreadiness.com/
· Email: jill@deathreadiness.com
· Learn more about Jill’s services: https://www.deathreadiness.com/solutions
· Subscribe to the Death Readiness Dispatch! https://www.deathreadiness.com/subscribe
-
“Avoid probate at all costs!” That’s what someone told me recently, but is probate really something we should be so afraid of? Today, we’re looking at two music legends that happened to leave messy probate estates: Michael Jackson and Aretha Franklin. We’ll also look at some surprisingly frustrating situations involving assets that never went through probate at all. And I’ll explain why a childhood encounter with an unhappy cat has something to do with all of this.
Welcome to The Death Readiness Podcast. This is not your dad’s estate planning podcast. I’m Jill Mastroianni — estate planning attorney, death readiness guide, and your translator for wills, trusts, probate, and the conversations most families avoid. If you’ve been wondering things like, ‘Can a trust protect what I leave to my children?’ ‘What happens if I give someone power of attorney over me?’ and ‘How can I help my parents while respecting their independence?’ You’re in the right place.
When I was about two years old, I watched a cat attack my mother. It was an unfortunate experience for everyone involved. My mom, the cat, and the two innocent bystanders, my brother and me. We were visiting a friend who happened to be a psychologist. My mom was afraid of cats, and apparently, my brother and I were, too. Our psychologist friend had a theory: We were afraid of cats because our mother was afraid of cats. She thought that if my mom would just hold the cat and show us there was nothing to be afraid of, we'd get over our fear.
Well, that plan backfired spectacularly. I imagine the cat picked up on my mom's fear, wasn't particularly thrilled about being held by someone who didn't want to hold it, and decided to make its feelings known. There was a lot of blood. At least, that's how I remember it. And I'm sure that over the past 42 years, my memory has embellished the scene to the point where the actual event probably bears little resemblance to the horror my brain has since created.
That was my one singular bad experience with a cat. One incident, reinforced by my mother's continued fear of cats, was enough to convince my brother and me that cats were terrifying creatures. And more than four decades later, we're still afraid of them.
But I've had far worse experiences with dogs. One morning, while I was running in Central Park with a friend, a dog came up behind me and took a chunk out of the back of my leg. One of our own dogs went through a period of intense fear when we first brought him home, and he bit me several times. And just yesterday, I was out running with our foster dog, Kobi, when another dog came charging after us.
Yet here I am, living in a house full of dogs, fostering more dogs, and voluntarily taking 4 dogs simultaneously out for walks. If any of those incidents had involved a cat, I might be too terrified to leave the house. So what's the difference?
I understand dogs. Or at least, I think I understand dogs. I've spent enough time around them to know that one bad experience doesn't mean every dog is dangerous. That familiarity gives me a certain amount of comfort. Cats, on the other hand? I don't understand them. And that one experience from when I was two years old has shaped how I feel about them ever since.
And I think the way a lot of people feel about probate is pretty similar to the way I feel about cats. They don't really understand it. Maybe someone they trust has told them that probate is terrible, they've heard horror stories, or they've had their own experience with probate, and it really was terrible.
But was it the probate process itself that made the experience so awful? Or was it something about that particular estate? Because those are two very different things. Just like I probably shouldn't judge every cat based on what happened when I was two years old, we shouldn't judge the entire probate process based on one bad experience.
Now, what got me thinking about all of this was a comment someone left on one of my social media posts last week. The comment was just five words: “Avoid probate at all costs!” At all costs? That's a pretty strong statement. And I imagine the person who wrote it may have had a particularly unpleasant experience with probate. Or maybe they've just heard enough horror stories to be convinced that probate is something to be feared in all cases.
Of course, avoiding probate can be a perfectly reasonable estate planning goal. What concerns me is the idea that we should avoid it at all costs. Sometimes the things people do to avoid probate end up creating much bigger problems than probate itself, like adding a child to their deed or their bank account. Doing so could expose your house and your bank account to that child’s creditors, including a soon-to-be ex-spouse of that child in a divorce proceeding. I’m not going to get into the details of those problems today but I’ll link to Episode 90, Why You Shouldn’t Add Your Child to Your Deed or Bank Account, in the show notes if you want to learn more.
Today we’re going to talk about whether probate is the monster people make it out to be. Probate is the court-supervised process for administering someone's probate estate after they die. This process generally involves identifying and collecting probate assets, paying debts and expenses, and distributing what's left to the people entitled to receive it. If you’d like to learn more about probate and why it can be helpful to avoid it, I’ll link to Episode 19, Why You Need (or Don’t Need) a Trust, in the show notes.
So, I'm not arguing that probate avoidance is a bad idea. But family disagreements, unclear instructions, missing information, complicated assets and people who don't agree about what the person who died actually wanted are way more problematic than the probate process itself. Let’s talk about two famous probate estates that have generated years of litigation, enormous legal expenses, and plenty of headlines. They illustrate something important: Sometimes probate is where the problems get sorted out but it isn't what caused the problems in the first place.
Earlier this month, I came across an article in The New York Times about Michael Jackson's estate. Now, Michael Jackson died in 2009. That's 17 years ago. And his estate is still being administered through the California courts. The headline of the article was: "Paris Jackson Asks Father's Estate to Fund $600M to Family Trust."
There's quite a bit to unpack here. First, Michael Jackson had both a Will and a trust. His Will was what's known as a pour-over Will. And I want to explain what that means because it's a common estate planning tool. When you create a revocable trust, the idea is generally to transfer your assets into that trust during your lifetime so they can be administered according to the trust's terms after your death, without having to go through probate.
But, if you forget to transfer something into the trust or you acquire an asset later and never get around to transferring it into the trust, that's where a pour-over Will comes in. A pour-over Will does not avoid probate. Those assets still have to go through the probate process before they can be transferred into the trust. And that's what Michael Jackson's Will directed.
His Will instructed his executors to transfer the assets passing through his probate estate into a separate trust he had created, called the Michael Jackson Family Trust. The Will itself is part of the public record. And if you're curious, I'll include a link to it in the show notes.
But the trust is a different story. The trust contains the instructions about who ultimately benefits from Michael Jackson's estate and how those distributions are supposed to work. Unlike the Will, the complete trust document is not publicly available through the probate proceedings.
At the end of October, Michael Jackson's daughter, Paris Jackson, filed a petition asking the court to require the executor to make a preliminary distribution of $600 million to the Michael Jackson Family Trust. John Branca, an attorney in the music industry, is currently serving as executor. He originally served alongside John McClain, who died earlier this year. According to Paris Jackson's petition, the executors have indicated that the estate is worth somewhere between $2 billion and $3 billion.
And according to that same petition, the Michael Jackson Family Trust provides for 20% of the estate to go to charity, with the remaining 80% going to a trust for Michael Jackson's three children.
Interestingly, John Branca isn't just the executor of Michael Jackson's estate. He's also named as a trustee of the Michael Jackson Family Trust. So even if he, in his capacity as executor, transfers $600 million from the probate estate to himself in his capacity as trustee of the trust, Paris Jackson is still going to have to deal with him.
Is Paris Jackson’s problem probate or is it John Branca? Well, I got my hands on the petition she filed and it very much seems that her problem is John Branca. But maybe that’s not entirely fair to him. We're talking about an extraordinarily valuable estate, complicated business interests, IRS litigation, and significant ongoing financial obligations. And John Branca or not, those complications don't disappear when assets move from a probate estate into a trust.
And that's the distinction I want you to understand. Avoiding probate doesn't mean avoiding estate administration. And it doesn't guarantee that your family will avoid disagreements. Michael Jackson's estate is an extreme example, of course. But the underlying lesson applies to much smaller estates, too.
A trust can be an excellent estate planning tool. It can help avoid probate, provide privacy, and make the transfer of assets more efficient. But it isn't a magic wand. And sometimes the problems that arise after someone dies have very little to do with whether their assets are passing through probate or through a trust, or both.
And, if you'd like more practical estate planning information like this, I send out a free email newsletter every Wednesday morning called the Death Readiness Dispatch.
It's where I continue some of the conversations we have here on the podcast. Sometimes I share resources or explain an estate planning issue that deserves a little more attention. Other times, it's behind-the-scenes stories, photos of my family or our foster dogs, or just something I've been thinking about that week.
It's free, and I'd love for you to be part of it.
You can subscribe at deathreadiness.com/subscribe. That's deathreadiness.com/subscribe.
Okay, let's get back to probate. Because our next celebrity estate involves the Queen of Soul. This one is a little closer to home for me, here in the Detroit area. Aretha Franklin died on August 16, 2018, at the age of 76.
And initially, it appeared that Aretha had died without a Will. When someone dies without a Will, their probate assets pass according to what's called intestate succession. That's just a fancy legal term for the rules each state has established to determine who inherits your probate property when you haven't left instructions yourself.
So, initially, it looked like Michigan state law would determine who inherited Aretha Franklin's probate estate. But then, about nine months after her death, on May 20, 2019, Aretha's niece, Sabrina Owens, who had been appointed to administer the estate, filed a petition with the Oakland County Probate Court.
While cleaning out Aretha's home, Ms. Owens discovered a key to a locked cabinet she hadn't previously been able to open. She opened the cabinet and found two handwritten documents, dated June 21, 2010, and October 20, 2010. Later that same day, while searching Aretha’s living room, Ms. Owens found another handwritten document. She found this third document, dated March 31, 2014, under the couch cushions. And these documents appeared to be Wills.
Now, you might be wondering whether you can actually write your own Will by hand and have it be legally valid. And the answer is, it depends on where you live. These are called holographic Wills. And here in Michigan, a handwritten Will can be legally valid if it meets certain requirements, including that it's dated, signed by the person making it, and that the material portions are in that person's handwriting. There are some additional legal considerations, but the important point is that in Michigan a Will doesn't have to be typed up by an attorney to be valid.
In July 2023, 4 years after Ms. Owens found the handwritten documents, a Michigan jury determined that the 2014 document, the one found under the couch cushions, was Aretha Franklin's valid Will. And that wasn't the end of the story. Because even after determining which document was the Will, there were still questions about what some of its provisions actually meant. If you're curious, I'll link to the handwritten documents in the show notes so you can take a look for yourself. They're difficult to read. And even when you can make out the words, figuring out exactly what Aretha intended isn't straightforward. According to reporting by the Detroit Free Press, the probate docket for her estate has accumulated more than 1,400 motions and other filings since her death.
And here's what I want you to think about. Was probate the problem? Or was the problem that Aretha Franklin left behind multiple handwritten documents, discovered in different places, with provisions that were difficult to interpret?
The probate court didn't create those problems but it did become the place where the family had to sort them out. Even if Aretha Franklin had created a trust to avoid probate, there still could have been disagreements about what the trust agreement meant, who was entitled to what, and how the trust estate should be administered. A trust doesn't eliminate the possibility of litigation or guarantee that family members will agree. And it definitely doesn't make unclear instructions any clearer.
So when we look at Michael Jackson's estate and Aretha Franklin's estate, we're looking at two very different situations. Michael Jackson had a Will and a trust, but his extraordinarily valuable and complicated estate is still the subject of disputes over its administration. Aretha Franklin left behind multiple handwritten documents, creating years of uncertainty about which one represented her final wishes and what those wishes actually were.
Both estates have been tied up in probate proceedings for years. But that doesn't mean probate is responsible for all the complications. Probate didn't create the disagreements. It provided a legal process for addressing them. And that's why I push back when someone says we should avoid probate at all costs. Avoiding probate doesn't mean avoiding litigation, family conflict, confusing documents, or the work involved in administering someone's estate. And sometimes, the steps people take to avoid probate create an entirely new set of problems.
Now, you might be thinking, "Okay, but Michael Jackson and Aretha Franklin aren't exactly representative of the average person's estate." Fair enough. So let's talk about some much more ordinary situations. Situations where assets are passing outside probate, but the people trying to collect them are still running into all kinds of problems.
I was recently talking with a friend whose mother had passed away. Before her death, her mother had assured her that she and her siblings were the beneficiaries of a substantial retirement account. So after her mom died, my friend called the financial institution to notify them of her death and find out what she needed to do to collect her share of the retirement account.
And she was told that she wasn't a beneficiary. When you call a financial institution about a deceased individual’s account and you're not listed as a beneficiary, the representative can’t tell you who is listed as the beneficiary. And even if the institution attempts to contact the actual beneficiary, that beneficiary isn’t likely to receive the notice if that beneficiary has moved since account owner made the designation.
Another example is from my personal experience. We bought our house in Michigan from someone who renovated the house after he purchased it from the estate of someone who died the year before. Ever since, we’ve been receiving mail addressed to this deceased person who apparently owned an IRA. I know this because the addressee line includes the person's name, followed by "IRA," followed by the word "deceased." Every time one of these envelopes arrives, I write "Return to sender. Addressee unknown" on it and put it back in the mail. I've even gone to the post office directly to report the error.
And yet, the letters keep coming. Now, I have no idea what's happening with this person's retirement account. But I do know that a financial services company continues to automatically send correspondence about a deceased person's IRA to an address where that person no longer lives. And apparently, despite my best efforts, nobody has figured out how to make it stop and get it to the right person, presumably the beneficiary of that account.
Here's one more example. I was helping a client whose sister had died as a young adult. My client was the designated beneficiary of her sister’s Roth IRA. There was no dispute about who was entitled to the account. So this should have been relatively straightforward, right? Well, not so much. We completed the paperwork. Submitted it. Followed up. Submitted it again. We made phone calls. Got transferred from one department to another. Explained the situation over and over again.
And every time we called, it felt like we were starting from scratch. After all those phone calls, all that paperwork, and all that time spent explaining the same situation to different people, we hadn't made any meaningful progress. Eventually, my client decided she needed a break. And I couldn't blame her.
I'm not going to name the company, but it's a big one. And I find it astonishing that a major financial institution could have such a disorganized process—or seemingly no coordinated process at all—for transferring an account to a properly designated beneficiary after the account owner's death. This isn't some unusual situation. People die every day. Financial institutions should know how to handle this.
And none of this had anything to do with probate. The account was supposed to pass directly to my client as the designated beneficiary. But avoiding probate didn't make the process simple.
And I think that's something we don't talk about enough. Death is a normal part of life. It happens every single day. You would think that the institutions responsible for managing people's money would have reasonably efficient systems for dealing with it. But anyone who's spent hours on the phone trying to close an account, transfer an asset, or get information from a financial institution after someone dies knows that isn't always the case.
Avoiding probate doesn't mean avoiding bureaucracy. It doesn't mean avoiding paperwork. And it certainly doesn't mean avoiding frustration.
Now, please don’t misunderstand what I'm saying. There are very good reasons to avoid probate.
But please don't avoid probate at all costs. The purpose of estate planning isn't to avoid a particular legal process at any price, but to make things easier for the people who will eventually have to manage our affairs. And we can do a lot toward that goal while we're alive.
We can create thoughtful estate plans, make sure our beneficiary designations are up to date, organize information about our assets, communicate with the people we've appointed to help us, and make sure they know where to find what they'll need.
But we can't eliminate every complication. We can't guarantee that every financial institution will be easy to deal with, that every family member will get along, or that every part of administering our affairs will go exactly as planned. And that's okay. We're not trying to leave behind perfection, just something much more manageable.
Which brings me back to the cats. Not all cats are scary. Not all probates are scary. Of course, there are scary cats and scary probates. And, as we've established, some pretty scary dogs, too. But I probably shouldn't spend the rest of my life terrified of every cat because of something that happened when I was two years old. And you probably shouldn't make every estate planning decision based on the assumption that probate is the worst possible thing that could happen to your family.
So keep doing what you're already doing. Ask questions. Learn about your options. Understand the tradeoffs. And make the decisions that make sense for you and the people you love. That's what death readiness is all about.
And here’s one more invitation to join me beyond the podcast.
Every Wednesday morning, I send out the Death Readiness Dispatch, my free email newsletter.
It's a little more personal than what we cover here. I share behind-the-scenes stories, photographs, practical resources, and sometimes things that don't have much to do with estate planning at all.
If you've enjoyed getting to know me through the podcast, I think you'll enjoy the newsletter, too.
You can sign up for free at deathreadiness.com/subscribe. That’s deathreadiness.com/subscribe.
Thanks for joining me today.
This is Death Readiness, real, messy and yours to own. I’m Jill Mastroianni and I’m here to help you sort through it, especially when you don’t know where to start.
Hi, I'm April, Jill's daughter. Thanks for listening to The Death Readiness Podcast. While my mom is an attorney, she’s not your attorney. The Death Readiness Podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes only. It does not provide legal advice. For legal guidance tailored to your unique situation, consult with a licensed attorney in your state. To learn more about the services my mom offers, visit DeathReadiness.com.